According to the authors, repetitive strain injury has become increasingly common. They cited recent Danish surveys revealing that more than half of female office workers reported frequent neck pain, and that more than two-thirds of female office workers who reported neck pain suffered from trapezius myalgia.
The team’s latest finding confirms that that five strength exercises – the one-arm row, shoulder abduction, shoulder elevation, reverse fly and upright row – substantially can reduce perceived pain. In particular, the team found that the women who had diminished ability to activate the muscle quickly and forcefully could benefit from the strength training.
The Study
Forty-two women who worked in offices on repetitive tasks and did computer work participated in the 10-week study. They all had reported chronic or frequent pain in the neck area, and tightness and tenderness of the upper trapezius muscle. The researchers randomly divided the women into three groups:
Specific strength training. This group of 18 women did five exercises with dumbbells – one-arm row, shoulder abduction, shoulder elevation, reverse fly and upright row. These exercises strengthen the shoulder and the neck muscles, including the trapezius. The women in this group did three sets of three of these exercises three times per week. The amount of weight lifted depended upon each woman’s strength level and progressively increased throughout the 10 weeks.
General fitness training. This group of 16 women cycled upright on a stationary exercise bicycle. Other studies have shown that general fitness training can help alleviate a variety of ailments. The researchers wanted to see whether the general fitness exercise would help improve rapid force capacity (the ability to activate the muscle quickly and forcefully) among those suffering trapezius myalgia. The women in this group bicycled three sessions per week for 20 minutes per session.
Reference (control). This group of eight women received individual and group counseling on ergonomics, diet, health, relaxation and stress management for a total of 1 hour per week. They did not receive any physical training.
The participants from all three groups performed shoulder abductions before the 10-week intervention began and after it ended. During this pre- and post-test, the participants were required to contract the muscles as fast and hard as they could. The researchers measured the force and speed of the lift. In particular, they wanted to measure rapid force capacity, that is, how quickly the women could activate their muscles to generate force.
They also obtained muscle biopsy samples to analyze how the training affected the muscle fibers and pain levels at each of the sessions. The pain data was compared to performance.
Strength Training Brings Relief
In this study, significant changes occurred only in the strength-training group. Strength training reduced pain levels by more than 50 percent, improved rapid force capacity and increased the number of type II muscle fibers (the fibers important in generating power).
The authors speculated that strength training reduced the pain, which then enhanced the body’s ability to rapidly activate the muscle. Activating the muscle depends upon rapid coordination of nerve signals and it was the nerve signaling that seemed to improve. The researchers added that the strength training may have encouraged the women to set aside the fear of pain and thus helped improve performance.
In addition to providing further evidence that these five exercises can help women who suffer trapezius myalgia, the study also showed that reduced rapid force capacity can be a good screening tool to determine who would benefit from this type of rehabilitation, the authors said.
The study, “Effect of contrasting physical exercise interventions on rapid force capacity of chronically painful muscles,” appears in the Journal of Applied Physiology, a publication of the American Physiological Society.
