EHS OutLoud Blog

Does Driving an Older Car Increase Injury Risk? NHTSA Says "Yes!"

So, we've been hanging on to our beloved model year 2000 (or older) cars. After all, they are paid for and everything seems to be working fine. But are we at a higher risk of injury by driving them rather than trading up to a 2008 or newer model? According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), yes!

In its June 2012 report, "An Analysis of Recent Improvements to Vehicle Safety,” NHTSA set out to determine what role vehicle safety improvements played in the historically low fatality and injury rates over the last several years.

NHTSA's data crunchers performed detailed statistical model analysis to ascertain if vehicle safety improvements since 2000 could be responsible for preventing injuries and fatalities. Their final conclusion is not surprising. The magnitude of those findings, however, is eye opening.

NHTSA reported results are rather noteworthy for a 2008 vs. 2000 model year vehicle:

  • The likelihood of crashing in 100,000 miles of driving decreased from 30 percent for a 2000 model to 25 percent for a 2008 car.
  • The likelihood of escaping a crash with no injuries? That improved from 79 to 82 percent when driving the newer car.
  • Improvements made to cars after the year 2000 prevented an estimated 700,000 vehicles from crashing.
  • The newer car improvements prevented or mitigated an estimated 1 million occupant injuries.
  • These improvements likely saved 2,000 lives in the year 2008 alone.
  • Of the 9 million crashes occurring among passenger vehicles in 2008, 200,000 could have been prevented by the newer safety systems.
  • Furthermore, the 300,000 injuries to 12 million occupants involved in crashes could have been avoided, with 600 lives saved.

Does this also apply to light trucks and vans? Absolutely, according to NHTSA.

Oftentimes, we safety professionals do not see the fruits of our labor at the end of the day, the week, the month or even the year. But according to this report, there's one thing we can do to potentially increase our safety while on the road: drive a newer car.

J.A. Rodriguez Jr., CEO of Make My Day Strategies LLC, is also an international Fortune 100 EHS senior manager, entrepreneur, a patented inventor, engineer, certified safety professional, professional speaker, member of the Industry Advisory Council at Western New England University, an elected Board Member of the national Voluntary Protection Program Participants’ Association, author of the book Not Intuitively Obvious – Transition to the Professional Work Environment, and an overall great guy.

Discuss this Blog Entry 4

Jeffzx9r
on Jul 17, 2012

The problem with this article is it does not address neglected maintenance of older cars. As I expressed to EHS Today, the overwhelming majority of people who drive older vehicles (especially in this economy) do so to “save money” but fail to understand how neglected maintenance (again; to save money) directly affects their safety. Sure, new vehicles have improved safety features, but that’s only part of the equation. To claim that older vehicles are somehow inferior is false logic. However, NEGLECTED older vehicles are indeed “higher risk.” Driving a newer car increases safety by virtue of not only the improved features, but due to the integrity of items which require routine maintenance and replacement. The article needs to address this factor.

frances
on Aug 13, 2012

Yes probably this could be a factor but it doesn't necessarily the one to blame. Because if so then what? People will buy new cars to replace their old ones just to avoid accident risks. I think this isn't a problem as there are a lot of car accessories in the market that help reduce the risks of injury. Another thing is a car must have a power steering, set of airbags, advanced seat belts,tire pressure monitoring and etc. to ensure safety.

simonfierce
on Aug 31, 2012

Well it could be but it's not about it if the car is old or not it is about maintaining the car in a good state even though its old. In my experien, i have an old car and im not scared of driving it on the road because i know im safe, i always maintain my car in a good state i always go to auto shop and do some tuning, parts checking and catalog parts checking. If there is a problem i will immediately fix it and repair it. Although there's a risk in old cars, it's about the people who use it. As i said always monitor and check your car's condition do a weekly or monthly check.

AndriaRobert
on Jan 17, 2013

Ya ,the points written above are right but that doesn't mean that there is a problem in buying an old car.If you drive well and maintain it well you can overcome many of these problems.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's EHS OutLoud Blog?

EHS OutLoud blog provides a candid look at health and safety issues both at work and at home.

Contributors

Sandy Smith

Sandy Smith is editor-in-chief of EHS Today magazine, a Penton Media Inc. publication. She has been writing about occupational safety and health and environmental issues since 1990. She has been...

Laura Walter

Laura Walter is senior editor of EHS Today, a Penton Media Inc. publication. She is a subject matter expert in EHS compliance and government issues and covers a variety of topics relating to...
Blog Archive