Group Issues Report Cards for State Workers' Comp Performance

July 23, 2004
A new study based on data from OSHA Form 300's and 200's, covering all OSHA recordable injuries and illnesses, provides the basis for state-by state rating of workers' compensation performance prepared by the Work Loss Data Institute.

The study, called 2004 State Report Cards for Workers' Comp, measured incidence rates, cases missing work, median disability durations, delayed recovery rate, and key conditions lower back strain and carpal tunnel syndrome.

Alabama was the "most improved" state in overall ranking, and received an "A." Utah also received an "A," with the report authors saying workers' compensation case outcomes in the state continue to improve. Indiana also has excellent outcomes, especially in minimizing missed work, and received an "A." Minnesota is one of nine states receiving an "A" in 2002, as were Georgia, Iowa and Virginia.

New Mexico has the unfortunate distinction of being the "biggest decliner" since 2000, when they got a "B+." The most recent grade was a "D." Texas has actually made some improvement, going from an "F" to a "D-." This improvement is primarily due to an excellent performance in prevention and safety (keeping the incidence rate of cases low compared to the population as a whole). However, when it comes to return-to-work (delayed recovery and median disability durations), Texas remains last.

California, the largest state, received a flunking grade. Performance was not good on all measures, but is close to the bottom when it comes to getting workers back on the job and preventing outliers, especially for carpal tunnel syndrome. According to the study, New York has gotten even worse. It received an "F," but went from being in the middle of the "F's" to being in last place as a state (and second to last after Puerto Rico). Other "F's" were received by Delaware, Hawaii, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, West Virginia and Wyoming.

A summary of each grade for all states is shown on a U.S. map located at www.odg-disability.com/pr_repsrc_us.htm.

The report also analyzes the association of specific managed care programs to outcomes by comparing the average ranking for those participating states with the program to the average ranking for those participating states without the program. Participating states with a state workers' compensation insurance fund did slightly worse than states with no state fund, with a decline in ranking of 1.2 points. Limiting provider choice seems to result in a very large positive difference in ranking, with states going up in the ranking by 9.5 points when provider choice is limited. Use of a fee schedule indicates a decline in the ranking by 3.4 points, and use of state-specific treatment guidelines manifests a decline of 5.9 points.

The 83-page WLDI special report, "2004 State Report Cards for Workers' Comp," can be purchased in hardcopy or electronic format for $225 each by calling WLDI at (800) 488-5548.

Sponsored Recommendations

3 Essential Elements for a Strong Safety Culture

March 13, 2024
Organizations globally have increased their attention on safety culture: trying to figure out what it really is and the aspects that are necessary to develop and sustain it. And...

Making the Case for Occupational Health Software

March 13, 2024
Deciding to invest in Occupational Health (OH) software can be a challenging leap for many organizations. This article will equip businesses with insightful strategies for effectively...

Fighting the Flu: Solutions for the Workplace

March 13, 2024
Seasonal flu continues to wreak considerable havoc both on individual wellness, as well as on our business continuity and productivity. Explore these solutions for protecting ...

Preventing SIFs with Digitization: Reduce Serious Injuries and Fatalities with Technology

March 13, 2024
This eBook discusses the origins of SIF prevention, outlines principles, models and tools available to EHS leaders to better detect and address SIF potential in their business...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of EHS Today, create an account today!